QUOTE (Feral Phoenix @ Jul 8 2006, 11:40 AM) | WRONG. |
I am never wrong.
QUOTE | I'm writing out (and almost have finished) a version of Chapter 8--with more plot--that has to do with MALICE surviving. |
That's just stupid. Malice died with Hector, and even if she didn't, Hector died and she failed her mission, so she would likely end her life there.
QUOTE | It's possible to do it whether or not Ledah lives or dies (I have separate versions of each during important scenes where Ledah or Ein would do a certain thing.) |
See? Even if Ledah doesn't need to be brought back, it still requires a "ZOMG ENEMY NOT DEAD" twist, which is stupid, and painful from a plot sense.
QUOTE | And while Hades does have a distant connection with the Accursed, his appearance after taking out the original ones (which is so much a typical, almost menial RPG task that it has almost no meaning to the player) doesn't make much plot sense. |
It's not distant, they are his servants. The reason he does not appear in the main story is because HE'S LOCKED AWAY.
QUOTE | Also, in regards to the Accursed, they just seem like a stupid boring task because the player never feels any *real* threat from them. It's just "Oh, no, they're going to take over Riviera with demons!", but you never *SEE* any of the damage they're supposedly capable of doing. |
Sure, but no, they did not feel like a stupid boring task to me. I knew the end of the game wouldn't come with the last Accursed, but I looked forward to each Accursed. Seeing what they looked like, getting their short backstory (sadly the Isher had none because we were too busy dealing with Ein's story), and then figuring out the best way to take them down. Best parts of the game, easily, were fighting the Accursed.
QUOTE | Malice is a much more threatening figure, due to the fact that we know she's killed Serene's people all on her own. |
See, I didn't see it that way. Partially because we don't know EXACTLY what happened to her family (eg, how she did it, we don't know if she stormed and razed the village, or snuck in at night killing like an assassin), and the other part being that Malice is never around. After 2-7, she disappears until 6-6. How threatening; a character that's never around. The Accursed, on the other hand, are always there.
QUOTE | She and Hector are the only villains in the game; |
Neither of them are villians. Probably the only villians in the game would be Hades and the Archangel, but we really do not know enough about Hades to say that, I suppose. Death could be considered one, but it's his job to prey on the sprites, so...
QUOTE | the Accursed are just convenient monsters used to keep the story going. |
No, they are convenient monsters to make Ein help with Hector's ambitions even as a traitor. He needed souls, and, as was said, it didn't matter whether they were sprite, demon or angel souls.
QUOTE | And while that wasn't Sting's intent, that's certainly how it feels to the player. |
Clearly not, or I wouldn't have spent this time responding like this.
~~~
Писатель всегда будет в оппозиции к политике, пока сама политика будет в оппозиции к культуре.
|