More Feral icons!, Malice set complete~ |
|
|
Feral Phoenix |
Aug 12 2006, 03:18 PM
|

Angelus Artifax
          
Group: Arcs
Posts: 1516
Joined: 28-December 05
From: Ancardia
Member No.: 29

|
At least I make submissions.
Thank you for the support, Mari, but really, if these guys don't want what I'm giving them, I don't have to give it to them.
Most of the fanstuff on this site is mine, remember.
I've used textures on icons before, but everyone has always whined that they're not visible enough. When I finally do get the textures visible and in an aesthetically satisfying way, then you guys start whining about how you can't see the image.
Well, really, you like Malice's icons just fine, and the images are even HARDER to see on hers.
I'll make icons my way, whether you have any particular respect for that or not. I don't just blindly follow somebody else's example so as to have an image that comes out exactly like theirs.
If you have no respect for originality, fine. I should've expected as much here.
But don't yap about how "ugly" my submissions are when it's pretty much only me and P.P.A. making submissions.
BTW, fansprites actually are meant to be taken--at least on that site. (And how in the world did you not remember the sprites, when so many of you kept saying how cute they were in the JP Riviera art topic??)
~~~
|
|
|
|
Rhiannon |
Aug 12 2006, 06:51 PM
|

I'm really moved by the chicken bone
           
Group: Gods
Posts: 2033
Joined: 23-December 05
From: Minnesotablarg
Member No.: 4

|
QUOTE | Well, really, you like Malice's icons just fine, and the images are even HARDER to see on hers. |
I don't remember saying I liked Malice's. <_< But either way, this isn't about Malice.
QUOTE | I'll make icons my way, whether you have any particular respect for that or not. I don't just blindly follow somebody else's example so as to have an image that comes out exactly like theirs. |
Fine, nobody wanted to give you constructive critism anyway. I'll remember to never even attempt doing it again. You'll never improve that way. Oh, and assumptions are bad. Just because I'm not flaunting my experimental avatars around in everyone's faces doesn't mean I'm doing the same thing over and over again and copying other people.
QUOTE | If you have no respect for originality, fine. I should've expected as much here. |
Are you saying your icons are original? <_< Ha ha ha.
QUOTE | But don't yap about how "ugly" my submissions are when it's pretty much only me and P.P.A. making submissions. |
No, it's not just you and P.P.A. Just because it's not in the submissions forum doesn't mean we aren't submitting things. HEY FERAL GUESS WHAT I MADE A SKIN. THAT TAKES A LOT MORE WORK THAN AN ICON DOES. HEY GUESS WHAT FERAL I FIXED THE WSC FACES. THAT WAS QUITE A FEW FACES, THERE. HEY GUESS WHAT FERAL I'M ALSO WORKING ON OTHER BIG PROJECTS RIGHT NOW.
Stop making assumptions.
~~~
|
|
|
|
Dr Strum |
Aug 12 2006, 07:01 PM
|

Can Lead the Nation with a Microphone
              
Group: Angels
Posts: 5427
Joined: 23-December 05
From: Seattle
Member No.: 1

|
QUOTE (Feral Phoenix @ Aug 12 2006, 10:18 AM) | At least I make submissions. ... Most of the fanstuff on this site is mine, remember. |
And we're, at least I'm, greatful for it. But you can't pretend that just because you submit doesn't mean you're exempt from criticism.
QUOTE | I've used textures on icons before, but everyone has always whined that they're not visible enough. When I finally do get the textures visible and in an aesthetically satisfying way, then you guys start whining about how you can't see the image. |
Because it shouldn't be about the effects. That's like when a game is made with gorgeous graphics and no other substance.
QUOTE | Well, really, you like Malice's icons just fine, and the images are even HARDER to see on hers. |
I don't think I've ever made any claim one way or the other about her icons, but the thing is, the art in her's is "harder to see" because of he way it's cropped. Not the way she's painted over the original image.
QUOTE | If you have no respect for originality, fine. I should've expected as much here. |
I'm curious as to what this actually means, but your icons aren't the most original.
QUOTE | But don't yap about how "ugly" my submissions are when it's pretty much only me and P.P.A. making submissions. |
I was the only one "yapping" about how ugly your icons were, and I only said it about the Soala one, and, in case you haven't noticed, I have high standards for anything regarding Soala. Like you with Ledah, when you rejected my one icon for poking some fun at Ledah's death.
~~~
Писатель всегда будет в оппозиции к политике, пока сама политика будет в оппозиции к культуре.
|
|
|
|
Leyviur |
Aug 12 2006, 07:58 PM
|

Just Some Guy
      
Group: Gods
Posts: 576
Joined: 24-December 05
From: Ground Zero
Member No.: 10

|
Don't be a bitch just because we don't readily jump on the circle jerk bandwagon. Nobody was insulting your icons (aside fro Sturm, and that was just barely - one out of a handful), we were all telling you that there was something wrong with one and how you could've maybe improved. If you can't take any opinions other than the ones you like, then you might as well get the hell off the internet, because it is RIFE with people who won't always see things your way.
Don't be arrogant just because you have control over the icontest and can judge other people's work, and suddenly expect saintly treatment from us because you have a somewhat successful thing going on; remember that without Sturm, you wouldn't even have a place to submit all those 'wonderful, original' icons to, and the most you'd be doing is using them on a no-name board as your avatar, nor would you even have that icontest going on.
We're not always going to be "oh my that is so sweet I'd print it out and put it on my wall if it weren't 100 x 100 pixels," so I'd suggest you get over it and actually take some of our criticisms to heart. We're not trying to ruin your 'works of art.'
|
|
|
|
Takara-chan |
Dec 18 2006, 02:25 PM
|
Unregistered

|
... Look, his icons are just FINE... (I'm SO out of place) Maybe to some people they need improvement... Look, I can't even USE photoshop. At least Feral knows how to put effects. Just think of all the criticisms pieces of advice and do it to improve your icons! :D
|
|
|
|
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
Invision Power Board
v2.1.4 © 2025 IPS, Inc.
|