Golden Sun was my favorite game before I came across Riviera. I love both games, and it tears me apart to choose, but even though the secong one is much longer and there's so much more adventuring to do, the first one just seems more famillar and comfortable to me. Don't know how else to describe it.
So I voted for GS1
EDIT: ah, yes. Air's Rock. I know it inside and out know, but I have to say, the first time I played it I found it quite frustrating and tedious. » Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
Then, at the end, all you get is Reveal, a spell that, in the first game, you get simply by talking to a monk.
(don't know if that needed to be a spoiler, but you never know...) This post has been edited by el Sethro: Aug 2 2006, 12:38 PM