Emelone = Odin? (BF7 Spoilers) Options

[Dr Strum]

Emelone is the "eternal" owner of the Gungnir in YU. The Gungnir is Odin's javelin.
Therefore, I submit to you, that Emelone is Odin, and that the Royal Army killed (a/the) God not even a quarter of the way through the story.

[Megaolix]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Odin

From this page : he is god of wisdom, war, battle, and death. He is also attested as being a god of magic, poetry, prophecy, victory, and the hunt.

I don't think that Emelone filled all those roles. And thus, she is not Odin.

...

What made you think so all of a sudden?

[Dr Strum]

he is god of wisdom,

She didn't seem wise?

war, battle,

Or good at fighting?

death.

She was killing humans like they were cheese.

[Megaolix]

I didn't said she couldn't fit in any of those roles, just not all of them.

And if she was supposed to be so good at fighting, why did she lose then?

[Rhiannon]

Because the Royal Army was strong, and they outnumbered her.

And I don't remember anything about Odin being a god of poetry.

[Megaolix]

And I don't remember anything about Odin being a god of poetry.

I'm not the one making the wiki articles...

But still, after reading that article, I can't really see Emelone as Odin. Not at all.

[Dr Strum]

I didn't said she couldn't fit in any of those roles, just not all of them.

I just showed you she fits all of them.

[Megaolix]

Sturm... You could be more convincing if you bothered to read my whole post...

From this page : he is god of wisdom, war, battle, and death. He is also attested as being a god of magic, poetry, prophecy, victory, and the hunt.

You just justified more or less the first sentence. What about he second?

[Dr Strum]

Because the last sentence is what he is "attested" to be, not what he is.

[Suzu Fujibayashi]

She died because she wanted to. If you speak to the Undines in the towns, you'll realize she never wanted to fight the humans at all. But since more Undines were like:
"RAWR HUMAN BLOOOOD."
She went with their wishes. But still, I can't see her as being a god... o_o

True the Gungnir is the lance of Odin, but it also makes appearances in a lot of games... Like Tales of Phantasia has a whole section of the game where a Valkyrie of Odin comes to take it from you. o_o

Besides...

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

The Royal Army won't be killin' any gods unless you initiate Ragnarok. ;P

[Dr Strum]

you'll realize she never wanted to fight the humans at all.

And that means she's not good at it, how?

True the Gungnir is the lance of Odin, but it also makes appearances in a lot of games... Like Tales of Phantasia has a whole section of the game where a Valkyrie of Odin comes to take it from you. o_o

And how is that unrelated to Odin? Because that is what you imply.

[Suzu Fujibayashi]

I wasn't saying she's not good at killing humans, I'm just saying she doesn't want too, so therefore you could assume she wasn't fighting all out... Just my own assumption.

I was saying that even though the Gungnir is the lance of Odin, this is a game and it doesn't mean this is the same Gungnir. Since, you know, the Excalibur makes an appearence in this game... Games like those legendary weapons, ya know?

On a random note: You always seem to be on when I never see anyone on. Are you a god or something!? D:

[Dr Strum]

I'm just saying she doesn't want too,

Which doesn't matter.

I was saying that even though the Gungnir is the lance of Odin, this is a game and it doesn't mean this is the same Gungnir.

You used an awful example to illustrate that point.

Are you a god or something!?

Do I have to point to my user group?

[Suzu Fujibayashi]

Yeah I suppose I did... The point is, this is a game so even though the Gungnir is said to be the lance of Odin, it doesn't have to be in the realm of YU.

That was meant to be sarcastic. I can read. <.<

[Raijinili]

Sturm, dying does not make you the god of Death.